A Closer Look at the Origins of Zynga’s Hidden Chronicles

Zynga raised some eyebrows earlier this week by announcing a hidden object game that, at a cursory glance, has an awful lot in common with both Playdom’s Gardens of Time and Game Insight’s Mystery Manor from visual style and setting to puzzle types. A closer look at origins of the game, however, reveals a deeper level of investment in the hidden object genre.

Several months ago, Zynga hired on game designer Cara Ely on as creative director. At that time, two significant things were happening in the video games industry — downloadable games-focused companies were scrambling to get into social and mobile distribution and Gardens of Time was killing it on Facebook. It’s not hard to imagine that Zynga wanted to get in on the hidden object game now that other companies had proven it to be a viable genre for a social network. The question was, would they simply copy the mechanics that worked in competing games or try to build a hidden object game from scratch.

This is where Ely’s history is important. She came to Zynga from I-play Games, one of the leading downloadable games portals oriented toward women with — you guessed it — a massive catalog of hidden object games. Ely spent five years at I-play developing franchises of hidden object games, most significantly the wedding-themed “Dream Day” series. Her design decisions in Hidden Chronicles are based on her learning rather than on the need to do what Playdom and Game Insight did in order to capture the same audience.

Here’s an example of a design decision Ely made for Hidden Chronicles: Do objects remain in the same place each time players attempt the same puzzle? In Gardens of Time, objects remain in the same locations each time the player attempts the puzzle. The only thing that changes consistently is the order in which the player is asked to find the items, and sometimes there are different items added to or subtracted from the list. In contrast, Mystery Manor changes the locations of objects between puzzles and uses word scrambles or silhouette recognition instead of traditional object lists to add challenge.

Based on her experience, Ely tells us it’s best to leave objects in the same place each time — as Gardens of Time does. Difficulty scales with each playthrough of that level by changing the list of items the player needs to find. She says it’s “too easy” if the same objects simply change locations with each playthrough because the player will go into the puzzle automatically looking for what’s visually different from the last time they player tried it.

Here’s another example: monetizing the hints system. Both Gardens of Time and Mystery Manor monetize a series of hints or gameplay advantage items like time-extension with premium currency or through friend gifts. Ely declined to get into specifics for Hidden Chronicles’ monetization, but did confirm that progression through the game’s 50 levels could be accelerated with premium currency and that hints could be gifted. She also confirmed that the game would feature leaderboards to track which of your friends finished puzzles with the highest score, and possible a “racing mode” where friends compete one-on-one to finish a puzzle in the least amount of time.

Zynga declined to provide any launch date details for any of the titles announced earlier this week at its Unleashed event in San Francisco. Hidden Chronicles was not playable at the event, but you can view the trailer shown to journalists here.

Mediabistro Job Fair

Mediabistro Event

Mediabistro Job Fair

Join us on January 27 at the Altman Building in New York City for an incredible opportunity to meet with hiring managers from the top New York media companies, network with other professionals and industry leaders, and land your next job! Register now!


Leave a Reply

6 Responses to “A Closer Look at the Origins of Zynga’s Hidden Chronicles”

  1. J Do says:

    Everything listed here is in Gardens of Time. What exactly were they trying to do differently???

  2. AJ Glasser says:

    Gardens of Time hides objects with anachronistic clutter and keeps the locations of said objects the same. When replaying a puzzle, the list of objects to be found differs only by half a dozen additions or subtractions at most — meaning the more you replay the puzzle, the easier it is to rack up bonus points on speed because you already know everything that you’re looking for and where it can be found. What Ely is describing is a system where you’re not looking for the same list of objects each time and as you can see from the video shown and the title screen itself, there’s much less visual clutter, indicating that the challenge scales differently than GoT’s progression.

  3. Inside Social Games · Vostu Settles Copyright Suits With Zynga in U.S. and Brazil says:

    [...] has made a conscious effort to avoid directly reproducing what works in other games, instead building new products within genres from the ground up. Vostu seems to be on a similar track, recently releasing Gol Mania, a soccer sim that [...]

  4. Inside Social Games · Zynga’s Hidden Chronicles launches today on Facebook says:

    [...] ex-EA art director Margaret Foley-Mouvais and longtime hidden object developer Cara Ely. as we’ve previously mentioned, the effort Zynga put into building this team suggests a deeper level of commitment to the hidden [...]

  5. Zynga’s Stock Rating Gets A Boost, And So Does Its Traffic | TechCrunch says:

    [...] getting positive reviews for its Boggle-like adaption to mobile. Hidden Chronicles, meanwhile, is led by an early creator of games in the hidden objects genre — it’s not a copy of a few competing titles, contrary to what many non-users have [...]

  6. How do you solve a problem like Zynga? – George Osborn – The Kernel says:

    [...] seen before. Like a certain game that feels like Farmtown. Or another that’s kind of similar to GardensofTime. Even Scrabble can’t escape from their copying [...]

Get the latest news in your inbox
interested in advertising with inside social games?

Social Media Jobs
of the Day

Social Media Manager

Social Media Manager
Santa Monica, CA

Social Media Manager

Honest Tea, Inc.
Bethesda, MD

Product Manager - Community Platform

Maker Media
San Francisco, CA

Featured Company

Join leading companies like this one and recruit from the nation's top media job seekers on the Mediabistro Job Board. Every job post comes with our satisfaction guarantee. Learn More

Our Sponsors

Mediabistro A division of Prometheus Global Media home | site map | advertising/sponsorships | careers | contact us | help courses | browse jobs | freelancers | content | member benefits | reprints & permissions terms of use | privacy policy Copyright © 2014 Mediabistro Inc. call (212) 389-2000 or email us